Volume III

Progress is now under way to pub­lish Vol­ume III! Check the Savas-Beatie Web­site or Ama­zon for an avail­abil­ity date. This book will include a chap­ter on the bat­tle of Shep­herd­stown Ford, and chap­ters on the com­mu­ni­ca­tions between McClel­lan, Lin­coln and Hal­leck before and after the Mary­land Cam­paign. There is also a sort of “exec­u­tive sum­mary” of the cam­paign, some cor­rec­tions to the pre­vi­ous two vol­umes, and a bio­graph­i­cal dic­tio­nary of over 1,500 peo­ple men­tioned in the books. More updates will fol­low, and thanks for your patience.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Letter from John T. Block, Louisanna Guard Artillery

I have posted this let­ter, not know­ing much at all about Block. His spelling and gram­mar are uncor­rected and his com­ments about the Shep­herd­stown bat­tle are quite inter­est­ing. Any infor­ma­tion about Block will be much appreciated.

John T. Block to Ezra Car­man, May 30, 1899, in Anti­etam Stud­ies, National Archives.
New Orleans May 30th 1899
Genl E.A. Car­man
Wash­ing­ton DC
My dear sir,
The “Louisiana Guard Bat­tery,” con­sisted of four (4) guns, two rifle and two how­itzers. Capt Edgar D’Aquin, Hays Louisiana Brigade, Ewells Divi­sion, Jackson’s Corps.
My rec­ol­lec­tion of the bat­tle of Sharps­burg, is, as fol­lows. After an all night march from Harpers Ferry, we crossed the Potomac, at or near Shep­perd­stown on the morn­ing of the 16th and marched out (I sup­pose was the Shep­pard­stown Road, where we halted for rest, then pro­ceeded down this road until dusk, when we filed in to a patch of woods with Hays Brigade.
This woods must have been in the neigh­bor­hood of the Church and near the line of bat­tle, as the pick­ets kept up a lively fire­ing all night, much to the dis­com­fort of Jackson’s foot cav­alry.
We remained in this posi­tion until one or two o’clock on the morn­ing of the 17th (I being on guard at the time) Gen­eral Jack­son and his staff rode up to where we had the horses pick­eted and wanted to know what Cav­alry is this; when informed that it was Artillery, He called for the offi­cer in com­mand and said to him, this is no place for your Bat­tery, get out of as quick as pos­si­ble. This wood will be shelled in a short time.” Day was just break­ing when we reached the open­ing, the shelling was very heavy at this time. We went to the rear out of range and camped on the side of the road.
It was early in the forenoon when we were ordered to report to Genl JEB Stu­art on the extreme left of our Army. Ime­di­ately took posi­tion on a Knoll in an open field.
I think we held this posi­tion until three or four o’clock in the evening. If I am not mis­taken the 13th Vir­ginia Reg­i­ment was the only Con­fed­er­ate Infantry on this part of our lines. Genl Stew­art, was with or near the Bat­tery while we were in action, and Genl Jack­son was with him for some time. This was a very hot place and kept the men at the Bat­tery hard at work. For­tu­nately our casu­al­ties were light, only one slightly wounded.
As I see the bat­tle field after so many years have elapsed is, that there was a ravine in front of us (dont know whether it was a stone fence or a stream) in our front, beyond this was an open space, the woods being some dis­tance back where the Fed­eral Troops were. In the open­ing in front of our bat­tery there was sev­eral trees (looked to me like apple trees) The Fed­eral sharp­shoot­ers were con­cealed in these trees and gave us a good [?] [of?] [?] until we found out where the Min­nies were com­ing from.
After leav­ing this posi­tion and on our way to the rear, to replen­ish our amu­ni­tion chest, a courier halted us and wanted know if we had any how­itzer amu­ni­tion, on being informed that we had, the two guns went into the fight again. If I am not mis­taken they went back through the woods they left in the early morn­ing.
Mr J.H. O’Connor, was with this sec­tion and may be able to give you some infor­ma­tion. Our camp on the evening of the 17th was on I sup­pose the same road that we marched from Shep­perd­stown. We entered through a dou­ble gate.
Dont remem­ber the date of retreat, our bat­tery was with the rear guard of the Army, took posi­tion on the heights of Shep­perd­stown to pro­tect the cross­ing of the rear of the Army. Our loss in this posi­tion was heavy in men and horses. A Fed­eral bat­tery took a posi­tion on the left of the ford and made it very warm for us for until we suc­ceeded in blow­ing up one of their Cais­sons.
Messrs Mark and O’Connor will send you their rec­ol­lec­tions of the bat­tle field.
Hop­ing by this poor descrip­tion of the bat­tery at Sharps­burg will assist you in locat­ing the posi­tion of our bat­tery.
I am
Very respect­fully
John T. Block
P.S. Our loss at Shep­perd­stown was three men killed by explo­sion of one shell and sev­eral wounded. The horses suf­fered most.
JTB

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Vol. II Review

And here is the review for Vol. II:

The Mary­land Cam­paign of Sep­tem­ber 1862 Vol­ume II: Antietam

Ezra A. Car­man, edited and anno­tated by Thomas G. Clemens

Savas Beatie, 2012, 670pp., $37.50

ISBN: 978–1-61121–114-6

Image cour­tesy of amazon.com

The clas­sic off The Mary­land Cam­paign of Sep­tem­ber 1862 has long been con­sid­ered a clas­sic in mil­i­tary lit­er­a­ture but some­thing which has been miss­ing in the doc­u­ment is anno­ta­tions. Upon read­ing pri­mary sources, there are some ques­tion­able things which have been writ­ten in these accounts, but with a good anno­ta­tion, the errors are cor­rected and sources prop­erly. Thomas G. Clemens has pro­vided these anno­ta­tions and are an excel­lent way to re-read this classic.

Ezra Ayres Car­man was born in Oak Tree, New Jer­sey and attended the West­ern Mil­i­tary Acad­emy in Ken­tucky. Dur­ing the Civil War, he fought with New Jer­sey units and faced some of the fiercest fight­ing through­out the war includ­ing the Bat­tle of Anti­etam. After the war, he was appointed to the Anti­etam National Ceme­tery Board of Trustees and the Bat­tle­field Board. Thomas G. Clemens has spent years study­ing the Mary­land Cam­paign and gained his doc­tor­ate at George Mason Uni­ver­sity. He has writ­ten a myr­iad of mag­a­zine arti­cles and has appeared in doc­u­men­taries along with being a licensed tour guide at Anti­etam National Bat­tle­field. Also, he is an instruc­tor at Hager­stown Com­mu­nity Col­lege and also founded the Save His­toric Anti­etam Foundation.

Much of vol­ume one deals with the Bat­tle of South Moun­tain and the process of reach­ing the bat­tle­field of Anti­etam. With­out vol­ume one, vol­ume two does not make much sense but both works stand as clas­sics. In order to appre­ci­ate the full con­text of Carman’s work, both vol­umes need to be read and with Clemens’ anno­ta­tions aid the work in the best way pos­si­ble. Thomas G. Clemens has per­formed a labor of love and his notes on the Bat­tle of Anti­etam are quite exten­sive. Through­out the text, there are quite a few good his­toric maps and the text is also fueled with many good pho­tographs of the field. The Bat­tle of Anti­etam is one of the most ter­ri­fy­ing expe­ri­ences from the Civil War and is con­sid­ered the blood­i­est day in Amer­i­can his­tory. In all of the works on the bat­tle, there are few which do not men­tion the work done by Ezra Car­men and since he was present at the bat­tle, the pri­mary source can be seen as more accu­rate than oth­ers. With­out the words of Clemens, there could be some con­fu­sion on the part of the reader not quite famil­iar with the bat­tle­field of Anti­etam or the rest of the Mary­land Campaign.

The Mary­land Cam­paign of Sep­tem­ber 1862 Vol­ume II: Anti­etam, stands on its own as a great work of Civil War lit­er­a­ture, but is more appre­ci­ated with both vol­umes. I highly rec­om­mend this book to any­one who has an inter­est in the Mary­land Cam­paign or is just inter­ested in the Bat­tle of Anti­etam. This in depth work by a Civil War vet­eran brings the hor­ror of the bat­tle­field to the reader and the anno­ta­tions of Clemens bring acad­e­mia to the work. These two vol­umes will be hailed as the great­est edi­tion of Carman’s work and a great addi­tion to the annals of Civil War history.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Review

This nice review of Vol. I & II was just sent to me. Thought I’d share it.

The Mary­land Cam­paign of Sep­tem­ber 1862 Vol­ume I: South Mountain

Ezra A. Car­man, Edited and Anno­tated by Thomas G. Clemens

2010, Savas Beatie, 576 pp., $37.50

ISBN: 978–1-932714–81-4

Image Cour­tesy of Barnes and Noble

Much has been writ­ten about the Mary­land Cam­paign sur­round­ing the Bat­tle of Anti­etam, but there have always been the clas­sics. As it is with clas­sics, espe­cially clas­sics which were writ­ten right after the war, they run out of print and are quite dif­fi­cult to get your hands on. For the longest time, I had heard of the great nar­ra­tive which Ezra Car­man had writ­ten on the entirety of the Mary­land Cam­paign but was never able to get it. That was, until Thomas G. Clemens and Savas Beatie released the work in an anno­tated fashion.

Ezra Ayres Car­man was born in Oak Tree, New Jer­sey and attended the West­ern Mil­i­tary Acad­emy in Ken­tucky. Dur­ing the Civil War, he fought with New Jer­sey units and faced some of the fiercest fight­ing through­out the war includ­ing the Bat­tle of Anti­etam. After the war, he was appointed to the Anti­etam National Ceme­tery Board of Trustees and the Bat­tle­field Board. Thomas G. Clemens has spent years study­ing the Mary­land Cam­paign and gained his doc­tor­ate at George Mason Uni­ver­sity. He has writ­ten a myr­iad of mag­a­zine arti­cles and has appeared in doc­u­men­taries along with being a licensed tour guide at Anti­etam National Bat­tle­field. Also, he is an instruc­tor at Hager­stown Com­mu­nity Col­lege and also founded the Save His­toric Anti­etam Foundation.

I should make one thing clear about this work. It is not a reprint. So many times when clas­sics are reprinted, that it all they do, but this one is not one of those works. Clemens anno­tates the whole doc­u­ment with mod­ern sourc­ing and exten­sive foot­notes. Pub­lished in two vol­umes, the first deals with the Bat­tle of South Moun­tain and some of the pre­lim­i­nary details of the cam­paign while the sec­ond deals with the Bat­tle of Anti­etam. The anno­ta­tions through­out not only give us an up to date look into the Mary­land Cam­paign with mod­ern sources, but a look into the mind of Car­man as he was writ­ing the work. Clemens tells us who Car­man was more likely to paint in a greater light because of his expe­ri­ences in the war and the pol­i­tick­ing going on between Lin­coln and McClel­lan through­out. While Car­man states that this was not just a bat­tle against armies, but a bat­tle between the high com­mand in Wash­ing­ton, Clemens adds that to tell us that not all was easy for the com­man­ders. One of the aspects of the cam­paign which is largely ignored is the action taken at Harper’s Ferry before the Bat­tle of Anti­etam and here, Car­man places it in his nar­ra­tive. The details of the cap­ture of Union sol­diers at the gar­ri­son is greatly impor­tant to the study of the cam­paign and here, it is given explicit detail through both the nar­ra­tive of Car­man and the anno­ta­tion of Clemens.

The Mary­land Cam­paign of Sep­tem­ber 1862 Vol­ume I: South Moun­tain is a great addi­tion to any Civil War library and is highly rec­om­mended for any reader. The excel­lent map sys­tem used in the book is a great aid to the nar­ra­tive and the anno­ta­tions are sec­ond to none. This is an excel­lent print­ing of this clas­sic and goes to show that there is more to write about when it comes to the Mary­land Cam­paign even if it is through anno­ta­tions. Thomas G. Clemens has done a fan­tas­tic job and has per­formed a labor of love by pour­ing his knowl­edge into this text. Highly recommended!

http://www.gettysburgchronicle.com/book-reviews/the-annotation-of-a-classic

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Volume Three

The third, and last, vol­ume of Carman’s man­u­script is now in the hands of Savas-Beatie. No word yet on pub­lish­ing date, but I hope later this year. It includes a chap­ter on the bat­tle of Shep­herd­stown Ford, and chap­ters sum­ming up the cam­paign, and also sup­ple­men­tal infor­ma­tion on the pre­lude to the cam­paign. A large por­tion of it is also a Bio­graph­i­cal Dic­tio­nary of every­one Car­man men­tioned in his nar­ra­tive, and also any vet­eran whose mem­oirs I cited in doc­u­ment­ing how Car­man knew what he wrote. In addi­tion to the com­man­ders this dic­tio­nary lists many com­mon sol­diers and junior offi­cers; peo­ple you will not find on Wikipedia! I’ll keep you posted on the progress towards pub­li­ca­tion, and will get back to post­ing more here too.

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments